Following this evaluation, GMU presented LARMAC with a Pavement Management Plan (PMP) Report, which provided essential information pertaining to the current condition of the streets and a recommendation for optimizing street conditions and estimating the cost to maintain at an appropriate level going forward. Implementing the recommendations from the PMP Report will extend pavement life and reduce the overall cycle cost over time of the Covenant Hills private streets.
Timeline of Events:
- April 6, 2022 - Future street repair recommendations and an updated funding plan were incorporated into the Covenant Hills Reserve Study in FY 2023, which was approved by the Board of Directors.
- June and July of 2022 - Highlights from the GMU PMP Study, as well as reserve contribution and funding information, were mailed to Covenant Hills homeowners.
- September 21, 2022 - A Town Hall meeting was held to address questions and provide a more in-depth look into the street issues and solutions for rectifying the issues. Presenters included GMU Engineering and LARMAC legal counsel.
Project Updates:
- Phase 1 - Phase 1 of the mutil-year street repair project was completed in November of 2022. The project included street repairs on the following streets: Anapamu, Ali, Sam, Basillica, Friar, Becker, Pointe, Kane and Hammonds.
- Phase 2 - Phase 2 of the multi-year project was completed in September 2024. The project included street repairs to the following streets: Katy Rose, John, Adele, Julia, Michael, David, Eric, Emmy and Jenny. This phase also included a seal coat on the streets listed above in Phase 1 as well as Cambridge Road.
- Phase 3 - Phase 3 of the multi-year project has been approved by the Board and is currently in progress, expected to be completed in October 2024. This project includes street repairs to the following streets: Lemonpeel Rd, Christopher St, Sky Ranch Rd, Pistoria Ln, Pisano St, Stockmen Rd, Cowboy Rd, Gaucho Rd, Vaquero Rd and Catalina Vista Rd.
Note - Localized repairs occur as needed and separate from the phased projects. As an example, a few sections on Covenant Hills Drive have been repaired knowing that Covenant Hills Drive street repairs are not planned until after all of the neighborhood streets have been completed, which is currently slated for 2032-2033.
As part of the FY 2025 budget review and approval process, future repair and replacement budgets were updated based on more recent construction costs, which have increased by about 35-50% on pavement projects since the PMP study, and initial cost estimates were established in 2021-2022. These updates have a significant impact on the funding plan, specifically the percentage funded, which is displayed below.
Included as part of the Reserve Study approval, an updated funding plan was approved for Covenant Hills. This funding plan has been designed to build up reserves to a sufficient level over the next several years to fund future asphalt repair projects.
Following large reserve contribution increases in FY 2023 (83.7%) and FY 2024 (64.4%), the current monthly reserve contribution only increased by 10.2% for FY 2025 (effective June 1), which equates to a $188.19 monthly reserve contribution. This is up from a rate of $56.56 from three (3) years ago. The updated reserve funding plan includes a more typical 5% annual reserve contribution increase for the next nine (9) years starting in 2024-2025. The plan then reflects a large reserve contribution decrease of 50% in year nine (2034-2035) to level out the funding levels. The exhibit below is a section of the updated funding plan which shows the estimated monthly reserve contribution year over year as well as the corresponding percent funded. As you can see from the exhibit below, the percent funded continues to slowly increase each year despite only factoring in 5% increases in the monthly contribution each year for the next nine (9) years. After a large decrease in 2034-2035, the anticipated monthly reserve contribution is estimated at $175.16 per month and the percent funded is expected to be 54%.
Note - The Reserve Study and Funding Plan are reviewed and updated annually as part of the budgeting process. Every year, updates are incorporated into the Reserve Study, such as actual expenses incurred vs. estimates that were budgeted. Additionally, life expectancies can vary based on actual experiences - all of which have an impact on the Funding Plan.
EXHIBIT: Reserve Funding Plan at a Glance
Additional Resources:
Pavement Management Plan (PMP) Report (May 26, 2021)
Presentation: Town Hall Meeting-Covenant Hills (Sept. 21, 2022)
Assumptions Used in Reserve Analysis